Are you wondering whether Meta Advantage+ or Google Performance Max should get the next dollar in your media plan? We recently ran a controlled 6-week split test on a DTC supplement brand spending $50,000 per month, and the results gave us a much clearer answer than another round of platform opinions ever could.
1) The test
What did we actually test? We split spend 50/50 between Meta Advantage+ and Google PMax, kept the product offering identical, and measured both platforms across the same 6-week window. That meant no cherry-picking hero SKUs for one side and no special promo structure for the other.
The account was a typical direct-to-consumer supplement business with an established conversion path, a healthy repeat-purchase pattern, and enough weekly volume to let both algorithms learn properly. In practical terms, that matters. If you run this test at $5k per month, you know, the data gets noisy fast. At $50k/mo, we had enough signal to compare platform behavior with confidence.
Actionable takeaway: If you want a real platform comparison, control the offer, control the window, and control budget allocation. Otherwise, you are testing variables, not channels.
2) The data
So what happened? On headline efficiency, Google PMax won.
- Meta Advantage+ delivered 3.2x ROAS and $28,000 in revenue
- Google PMax delivered 4.1x ROAS and $36,000 in revenue
If we stopped there, we would simply move more budget into PMax and call it a day. But let's face it, platform reporting only tells part of the story. When we looked deeper into customer mix and order behavior, the difference between the two systems became much more useful.
Actionable takeaway: Use ROAS as your first filter, not your final verdict. Efficiency without customer context can lead to underinvesting in growth.
3) The audience difference
Where did each platform actually create value? This is where the split became interesting.
Meta Advantage+ drove 68% new-to-brand customers.
Google PMax drove 34% new-to-brand customers.
That tells us Meta was doing more demand creation, while PMax was doing more demand capture. In other words, Google harvested buyers who were already closer to purchase, while Meta introduced the brand to people earlier in the decision journey.
We see this pattern often with health and supplement brands. A shopper might discover the product through a creator-style video on Meta, then come back later through a branded or high-intent Google path. So yes, PMax looked stronger on direct efficiency, but Meta was influencing future demand in a way last-click style reporting can understate.
Actionable takeaway: Track new-to-brand rate alongside ROAS. If one platform is bringing in twice as many new customers, that has real compounding value over 60 to 90 days.
4) The AOV difference
What about order quality? Bear in mind, the two platforms also drove very different basket behavior.
- Meta Advantage+ AOV: $64
- Google PMax AOV: $89
Why the gap? Meta users behaved more like exploratory buyers. They responded to the message, clicked through, and often entered with smaller first orders. Google users were more intentional. They arrived with stronger purchase intent and were more likely to choose higher-value bundles or commit with less hesitation.
For supplement brands, that difference matters operationally. Lower AOV on Meta does not automatically mean lower quality traffic. It can mean earlier-funnel customers who need better bundle design, stronger post-purchase flows, or a more deliberate upsell sequence.
Actionable takeaway: If Meta is producing lower AOV, test starter bundles, subscription prompts, and post-purchase upsells before concluding the platform is weaker.
5) The optimal mix
So what mix actually won? After reviewing the split, the strongest allocation was:
- 60% Google PMax
- 40% Meta Advantage+
That blend produced a 3.7x ROAS and the highest total revenue at $34,000 across the optimized allocation model. Why did it work? Because it balanced bottom-funnel efficiency with top-funnel demand creation. PMax converted existing intent better, while Meta kept filling the pipeline with new prospects.
Actionable takeaway: Allocate more budget to the channel that captures intent, but keep enough spend in the channel that creates it. Cutting discovery too aggressively usually hurts future revenue.
6) The takeaway
Should you pick Meta Advantage+ or Google PMax? In this account, the answer was clearly no.
Use Google PMax for bottom-funnel efficiency, stronger AOV, and higher immediate ROAS. Use Meta Advantage+ for top-funnel growth, new customer acquisition, and category expansion. Together, they do different jobs, and the account performed best when we let each platform play to its strength.
What are you seeing in your own account right now: stronger immediate returns from Google, or better new-customer momentum from Meta? And if you ran this exact 60/40 split for the next 6 weeks, what would you expect to happen to your blended ROAS?